How can I stop my daughter feeling caught in the middle and improve communication with my ex-partner?
Dear Marcie
My former partner and I rarely communicate directly. We often ask our 12-year-old daughter to pass messages between us about arrangements, school events and activities. Recently she told me she feels "stuck in the middle" and worries about upsetting one of us. We both love her very much but seem unable to communicate without conflict.
What concerns would you have about this situation from our daughter’s perspective. What practical steps would you suggest to move communication back to the adults. Are there any signs we should look out for to indicate that our daughter is carrying too much emotional responsibility. How can we rebuild trust and cooperation after years of conflict.
Thanks so much
TH
______________________________________________________
Dear TH,
The thing that jumps out at me here is that your daughter has actually told you very clearly what she needs: she doesn’t want to be in the middle anymore.
At 12, she may be perfectly capable of remembering that netball is at 5pm or that there is a school event next Thursday. But that doesn’t mean she should be responsible for passing that information between two adults who find it difficult to communicate. Because she isn’t just carrying the message. She is carrying the emotional weight that comes with it.
She may start wondering: How will Dad react when I tell him? Will Mum be cross if I say this? Should I change the wording? Is it my job to make sure they don’t argue?
That is far too much responsibility for a child.
So, the first practical change I would make is a really simple one: agree that from now on, adult information travels adult to adult. It doesn’t have to mean long conversations. In fact, if communication is difficult, I would make it short, factual and predictable.
Think: “Parents’ evening is Thursday at 6pm. The school has sent the details by email.” Not: “I assume you’ve forgotten parents’ evening again.”
One of the tools I teach parents is to strip a message back to its purpose. Before you send it, ask yourself: What does the other parent actually need to know? Then send that and nothing else.
I would also go back to your daughter and say something like: “You were right to tell us you felt stuck in the middle. It isn’t your job to carry messages between us. We’re going to sort that out ourselves.”
That can be enormously reassuring.
Signs that she may be carrying too much emotional responsibility include worrying about either parent's feelings, trying to keep the peace, withholding information because she is frightened it will cause an argument, feeling responsible for arrangements, or becoming anxious around handovers and conversations about the other parent.
As for rebuilding trust after years of conflict, don’t start by trying to fix the whole relationship. Start much smaller.
Trust grows when behaviour becomes predictable. Reply when you say you will. Keep messages respectful. Don’t use your daughter as the go-between. Do what you have agreed. Let small things go.
You don’t need to become friends. You need to show each other, repeatedly, that when it comes to your daughter, you can both be safe pairs of hands. And that starts with taking her out of the middle. In my book The Co-Parenting Method, step four which is all about boundaried communication will be helpful.
Best
Marcie